Insights

Staying On Time in NYC When Rain, the Marathon and Train Delays Hit

Photo by Dominik Gryzbon on Pexels

Mike Wills Jr.
By Mike Wills Jr. · Co-Founder & CEO · · 10 min read

Getting across New York City on time is harder than it looks on a map. A trip that’s easy on a normal Tuesday can take much longer when it’s pouring, and on some Sundays the street you need is simply closed. Our cleaners get to homes all over the city by bus and train, so I probably spend more time thinking about this than most people would want to.

What I’ve come to believe is that most of it happens the day before. By the morning, most of your options are already gone. If the trains are down at 7 a.m., there isn’t much you can do at 7:15 except wait. You can try to book a car, but so is everyone else on that platform, and the wait for a ride gets long fast.

Getting there on time starts with checking the forecast and street closures

The day before is when we look at what’s coming. Is rain in the forecast, and is it the light kind or the kind that floods a few stations? Is there a parade, a street fair, a bike tour or a race closing streets near the homes on the schedule? None of those take long to answer, and the answers change how the next morning gets planned.

For the trains and buses, we check the MTA’s service alerts page. It lists planned work and service changes on the subway and buses, often days ahead, so a line that’s going to be down on Saturday isn’t a surprise on Saturday morning.

The MTA Planned Service Changes page at mta.info/alerts, showing route filters for subway, bus, LIRR and Metro-North and a list of subway lines with no planned changes

Once you know what’s coming, you can build some slack into the day. That might mean leaving earlier, taking a different route, or putting the homes in an order that keeps someone on one side of a closure instead of crossing it twice. A cleaner who leaves early and gets there with time to spare has given up a little time. A cleaner who leaves on the usual schedule and hits a dead train line can lose the whole morning.

Travel time between cleaning jobs gets planned from home and back

The weather and the alerts tell you what’s different about tomorrow. The other thing we look at is the trip itself. Our scheduling board pulls subway and bus travel times from Google Maps for every part of a cleaner’s day. That’s the ride from their home to the first job, the ride between each job, and the ride from the last job back home. The times are based on the train and bus schedules for that hour, so a trip at 9 a.m. and the same trip at 3 p.m. can come out different. When a job gets booked or moved, the board looks up the new trip on its own and updates within seconds.

What we’re looking for is a day that actually works from start to finish. If the ride between two jobs is longer than the gap between them, the board marks it, so someone can fix it the day before instead of finding out the morning of. A long ride home gets flagged too, since a cleaner’s day doesn’t really end until they get home. We also look for room for lunch somewhere in the day, instead of a straight run from the first job to the last.

Distance matters too. We try to give a job to a cleaner who lives closer to it first. The exception is when you have a set cleaner on a recurring plan, or you’ve asked for a certain cleaner. Then we keep that cleaner, even if they live farther away. Every so often a job is really far from the home of the only cleaner who can take it, and there’s no closer option. When that happens, we figure out how to get them there on a case by case basis.

The other half of planning the day before is having a backup ready. What I’ve learned is that the backup has to match what’s actually broken, and that’s the part that’s easy to miss.

Subway delays in the rain and marathon street closures need opposite backups

Heavy rain and a big street closure both make people late, so it’s easy to treat them the same way. They really aren’t the same. In a storm, the streets still work. Traffic is slower, but a car can still get from one place to another. What breaks is the buses and the trains. Buses crawl, some subway lines flood or get suspended, and a train that’s supposed to come every few minutes sometimes just doesn’t show up.

The trouble doesn’t always start near the home being cleaned, either. Some of our cleaners live in neighborhoods where a heavy storm can flood the streets or shut down the one train line nearby. On those days, getting out of their own neighborhood is the hard part.

On marathon day it’s the other way around. The trains mostly run. What breaks is the streets, and the buses that run on them. The NYC Marathon is the first Sunday in November, and it was here again earlier this month. It starts on Staten Island at the Verrazzano, runs through Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and Manhattan, and finishes in Central Park. Along that whole line, streets and the bridges the race crosses are closed for hours, some of them for most of the day. The same thing happens on a smaller scale with the Thanksgiving Day Parade, the Five Boro Bike Tour, the Pride March and the street fairs that close a few blocks on a summer weekend.

So the backup depends on which thing is broken. If the trains are down, you want something on the streets. If the streets are closed, you want something underground.

When heavy rain shuts down a subway line, a car service can be the backup

When a storm knocks out the trains a cleaner depends on, we sometimes send a car service to get them where they need to go. Not every rainy day calls for it. A lot of the time, leaving early and taking a different line is enough. But when the line someone needs is suspended and the bus is stuck in traffic, a car can be the only reasonable way to get them to the home close to on time. Now and then we do the same for other reasons too, like a long outage on one line or a closure nobody saw coming.

Heavy snow is different. On the heavier snow days, when the trains slow down and side streets aren’t plowed yet, we try to cancel in advance. Hearing about it ahead of time is a lot better than finding out the morning of.

NYC Marathon street closures make the subway the better backup

Marathon Sunday flips all of that. Our cleaners mostly ride buses and trains, so for us the closures show up as bus trouble. Bus routes that cross the course get detoured or cut short, and some buses just don’t show up that morning. A car isn’t much better. Getting around the course can mean going far out of the way and then sitting in traffic with every other driver trying the same few open crossings.

So on marathon day the plan leans on the subway. We look at where the course runs, see which homes sit on the far side of it, and plan routes that go under it instead of around it. Sometimes the better move is to arrange the day so a cleaner’s homes all sit on one side of the course. That kind of thinking has to happen ahead of time, because by the morning the closures are already in place.

The worst day would be a storm on marathon day, when the trains and the streets are both in trouble at once. Luckily I can’t remember the last time that happened. If it ever does, it’s the same thinking with less room for error, so the planning starts even earlier.

If you have a house cleaning in NYC on a day you know will be messy, it helps to tell us anything about your block we might not know, like a street fair right outside or a building entrance that’s blocked off. The same goes for an apartment cleaning in a building where the usual door is closed for the day. And if you’re picking a day yourself, you can see what’s open when you book online and steer around the big event days if you’d like.

Staying on time in NYC is a planning habit anyone can use

None of this is special to cleaning. It’s how I’d think about any morning in this city where being on time matters, like a job interview, a flight or a doctor’s appointment. Check the weather and the event calendar the night before. Ask what’s most likely to break. Then pick a backup that still works if that thing breaks.

The last part is the tricky one. The usual backup is “I’ll grab a cab if the train is bad,” and that’s a good plan in the rain. On marathon day, or the morning of the parade, it’s probably the worst one you could pick.

So when I think about being on time in New York, I’ve found most of it comes down to the day before more than the commute itself. Look at the day ahead the night before, leave some room, and keep a backup that fits what’s actually broken.

Common Questions

Will my cleaner still come if it's pouring rain?
On a normal rainy day, yes. Rain changes how we plan the trip more than whether the cleaning happens. The day before, we look at how heavy the storm looks and build in extra time, like leaving earlier or taking a different train line. When a storm knocks out the line a cleaner depends on, we sometimes send a car service to get them there. Not every rainy day calls for it, but when the train is suspended and the bus is stuck in traffic, a car can be the best way to get there close to on time.
What if my street is closed for the NYC Marathon or a parade?
We look at where the course or the parade route runs the day before and plan around it. On marathon day the trains mostly run, but the streets along the course are closed, and the buses that cross it get detoured or don't come at all. So the plan leans on the subway instead of a bus or a car. Where we can, we also arrange the day so a cleaner's homes sit on one side of the course. If your block or your building's entrance is affected, telling us ahead of time helps.
What happens to my cleaning on a heavy snow day?
On the heavier snow days, when the trains slow down and side streets aren't plowed yet, we try to cancel in advance. That way you hear about it ahead of time instead of the morning of.
What should I tell you about my block on an event day?
Anything we wouldn't see on a map. A street fair right outside, a building entrance that's blocked off for the day, a side door that's open when the main one isn't, or a doorman who should expect the cleaner. Those are easy details for you to know and hard for us to find out the morning of.
Should I avoid booking a cleaning on marathon day or a stormy day?
You don't have to. Those are the days we plan for the most, and the planning happens the day before. But if you're picking a day yourself and would rather skip the big event days, you can see what's open on our online booking calendar and choose a quieter one. Storms are hard to predict that far out, so for rain I wouldn't worry much about the date you pick.
Mike Wills Jr.

Co-Founder & CEO

I've been running Maid Marines in New York City for over a decade. Born and raised in Queens, still here with my wife and two kids. We've cleaned more houses and apartments in this city than I can count, which means I've spent a lot of time thinking about what happens in people's homes, why they hire help, and what separates a cleaning company people trust from one they tolerate. I write here because the business generates enough real observations that it's worth writing them down.

Ready for a spotless home?

Book Your Home Cleaning ➜
Book Now